The Open Hand
The trial a Master Monk takes to become a Asura.
1. Nothing in the Hand
- Offered from
- Lv 150 (its maps stand at Lv 152)
- Given by
Mother Ashra of the Open Hand,
Pinehaven- Hand in to
- The same
Steps
- Speak to Brother Oren in
Pinehaven - Examine the Cyclops's thrown boulder, split in two in
The Odyssey: The Wooded Islands - Defeat Cyclops ×15 on
The Odyssey: The Wooded Islands
Reward
- 314,785 base XP · 157,392 job XP
- 14,731 gold
- Adamantium ×7
- Premium Green Bottle ×4
The offer
Shen Tao taught you to strike before the sound. I will teach you to strike with nothing at all. Put your claws down, child. There. Does the hand feel empty? It is not. It is only open.
On the Lotus Shore of the Wanderings, the Cyclops threw a boulder that split in two. Go and look at it. Then meet his kind with your hands open. Can you?
While it is under way: “Open hands. If you clench, you have already let go of something.”
Conversation with Brother Oren (Pinehaven)
Opening
Brother Oren: Strength through stillness. Ah, and you have put your claws down. Mother Ashra's work, I see. She did the same to me, once. I have not picked mine up since.
Brother Oren: You will want the lecture, I expect. Everyone does, eventually. I shall keep it short, since you have giants to visit.
→ Ask
Ask
“What can an open hand hold?”
Brother Oren: Everything, and nothing in particular. A fist holds one thing very hard. An open hand holds whatever is put in it, and lets go when it is time. Ashra would say it better, in fewer words. She usually does.
→ Ask
“Why did you never pick your claws up again?”
Brother Oren: Because I found I was gripping them even in my sleep. A monk who cannot open a hand is not a monk at all, only a fist with opinions. Put like that, it was not a hard choice.
→ Ask
“How do I meet a giant with empty hands?”
Brother Oren: A giant is strong because it grips: the boulder, the ship, the sailor. Give it nothing to grip, and its strength has nowhere to go.
You: And if it grips me?
Brother Oren: Then do not be there. Shen Tao would say be faster than the ear. Ashra would say be emptier than the air. I say both, and eat something first.
— Step done.
On handing in
You stood before giants with nothing in your hands, and they fell. Not because you were strong. Because you were not holding on to anything they could take.
2. The Giants' Fists
- Offered from
- Lv 150 (its maps stand at Lv 158)
- Given by
Mother Ashra of the Open Hand,
Pinehaven- Hand in to
- The same
Steps
- Gather Laestrygonian Knucklebone ×8 from Laestrygonian on
The Odyssey: The Wooded Islands - Speak to Grandmaster Shen Tao in
Pinehaven
Reward
- 294,974 base XP · 147,487 job XP
- 14,668 gold
- Adamantium ×7
- Premium Green Bottle ×4
The offer
The Laestrygonians crush ships with their fists. Bring me their knucklebones, so Shen Tao can see what a closed hand is worth against an open one.
Then go to him, and show him. He will grumble. Let him grumble. It is how he learns.
While it is under way: “Knucklebones, then Shen Tao. Be kind to him; he was my best student.”
Conversation with Grandmaster Shen Tao (Pinehaven)
Opening
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Listen. That was a leaf landing. If you heard it land, you were too slow to catch it.
Grandmaster Shen Tao: So. Ashra sends you back with a sack of giants' knuckles, and that look on her face I can feel from here. Go on, then. Show me.
→ Reply
Reply
“These are the Laestrygonians' knucklebones.”
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Hm. Big. They crush ships with these. And you carried them back in a sack, with your hands open. I see.
→ Test
“Mother Ashra says you were her best student.”
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Did she. She has never once said it to me. I shall pretend I did not hear. ...Show me the bones.
→ Test
“She says you will grumble.”
Grandmaster Shen Tao: I do not grumble. I comment, at length. Show me the bones.
→ Test
Test
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Before I look at them properly, I will hear it from you: what I taught you, and what she has. Five things. You may drop one. I always drop one; Ashra says that is the trouble with me.
→ Exam
Exam
A test: 4 of 5 right to pass (pass · fail; a failed test can be retaken).
- A Monk strikes. What has a Master Monk done?
- Struck twice
- Waited for the sound
- Struck already; the sound comes after✔
- What did I split by the Pinehaven gate, with one palm?
- A boulder✔
- An anvil
- The gate itself
- A Master Monk does not push. What does a Master Monk do?
- Pulls
- Arrives✔
- Waits
- Ashra says your hand is not empty. What is it, then?
- Ready
- Strong
- Only open✔
- Why did the giants fall before your open hands?
- You were stronger than they were
- You held nothing they could take✔
- They were tired of fighting
Passed
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Yes. ...Yes.
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Leave them with me. The bones. I should like to sit with them a while.
You: Grandmaster?
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Go on, child. Tell Ashra I commented at length. She will know I did not.
— Step done.
Failed
Grandmaster Shen Tao: No. You are still gripping something. I can hear it. Go and open your hands, and come back.
— The conversation ends; talk again later.
On handing in
Shen Tao sat with the knucklebones a long time. Then he took off his claws and put them on the shelf. He did not say anything. He did not need to.
3. The Whirlpool
- Offered from
- Lv 150 (its maps stand at Lv 159)
- Given by
Mother Ashra of the Open Hand,
Pinehaven- Hand in to
- The same
- Where
- A story instance of your own (it drops nothing)
Steps
- Speak to Grandmaster Shen Tao in
Pinehaven - Stand at the lip of the whirlpool, open-handed (180 s, story) in
The Odyssey: The Sea Road
Reward
- 199,970 base XP · 99,985 job XP
- 8,510 gold
- Adamantium ×4
- Premium Green Bottle ×2
- a gold piece of gear
- the title “the Open Hand”
The offer
Your trial, hero. Go to the strait, to the lip of the whirlpool that swallows ships whole, and stand there with open hands while the sea pulls at everything you are holding.
Hold on to nothing. Then nothing can be taken from you. Go.
While it is under way: “The whirlpool takes what you grip. Grip nothing.”
Conversation with Grandmaster Shen Tao (Pinehaven)
Opening
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Listen. ...No leaf this time. Only my own hands, doing nothing. It is very loud.
Grandmaster Shen Tao: You are going to the whirlpool. I went once, at your age, with my claws on. It took them. I came back and bought new ones. I have been buying new ones for forty years.
→ Ask
Ask
“How does it feel, without the claws?”
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Cold. Light. Like the first morning after a long illness. I keep reaching for them. Ashra says I will stop reaching in a year or two. Ashra says a great many things and is right about most of them. It is unbearable.
→ Ask
“What happened at the whirlpool?”
Grandmaster Shen Tao: It pulls at whatever you grip. I gripped my claws, so it pulled at them, and I gripped harder, and it pulled harder. In the end I let go only because it was that or go down with them. I called that losing. Ashra calls it my first lesson.
→ Ask
“Any last lesson, Grandmaster?”
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Mine is no use to you now. Faster than the ear: that was for a fist. Ashra's is the only one that matters at the lip of that water.
You: Hold on to nothing.
Grandmaster Shen Tao: Then nothing can be taken. Yes. Go on. I shall be listening for you. If I hear you land, you were too slow.
— Step done.
On handing in
The whirlpool turned for three minutes and took nothing, because you had nothing to give it. You came back lighter than you left. That is the whole of it.
Rise an Asura, hero. Nothing in the hand. Nothing needed in it.
Story moment
Mother Ashra of the Open Hand: Open your hands, child. See? Empty. And everything is still here.
The Open Hand: At the lip of the whirlpool a figure stood with open palms while the sea tore past. When the tide turned, the whirlpool had taken nothing at all.